IMO Shimano bikes are good,but they are 2 steps down compared to Specialized and Bosch. Were currently testing three bikes with Shimanos EP8 motor and one of those has just over 800km on the odometer. e-bikes remove the only non-financial barrier for entry into a sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness. Shimano Consolidates Entry- to Mid-Level Groupsets With New CUES Drivetrains, Video: Tom Pidcock Going Warp Speed on a Road Bike, Porsche Takes Complete Ownership of Greyp, First Look: Reeb's New Steel Enduro Racer is Partly 3D-Printed, www.gumtree.com.au/s-ad/wanneroo/bicycle-parts-and-accessories/men-s-petrol-bike-mountain-bike-/1259285475, www.cyclevolta.com/story/ebike-components/hold-up-shimanos-new-emtb-motor, www.avdweb.nl/solar-bike/solarbike/maxun-solar-bike. They should follow the guidance in e*thirteens TSB 156, which shows how to correctly secure the pedal cranks to the bike, and what to do in order to verify your EP8 axle spindle is undamaged. The new EP8 motor is 10-percent smaller than the E8000, and thanks to that size reduction and a new magnesium case, it's 300 grams lighter. Oh man, so that must mean you know of rigs they've received that they've not done first rides and then field tests on. You've been subscribed to our newsletter. What makes me sad is seeing young people hop on the e bike train so that they can go on a longer ride or so that someone who is new to cycling can keep up with their friends who have been riding for years, all to perpetuate needless consumerism and a gross waste of resources. You can improve efficiency by limiting the maximum torque, though it is still possible to get maximum power out of the motor by pedalling at a higher cadence, so you wont necessarily get more range by limiting torque. I swapped wheels but didn't realize I had to swap the magnet from the rotor bolts that was connected to the speed sensor in the software. One is a Haibike Fat-Tire with a Yamaha Drive, the second is an absolutely brilliant 40lb (including battery) DIODE from LaMere Cycles in the USA. While the motor is both more sensitive and more powerful though, Shimano has done brilliantly to offer usable control of that power. I have never posted a comment here on pinkbike, however this article in particular is hitting a nerve. 2023 Thok TK01 R Review | A surprising package from an Italian e-MTB specialist, 2022 Canyon Spectral:ON Review | A better e-MTB in almost every way, 2023 Trek Fuel EXe Review | This brand new lightweight e-MTB is the stealthiest weve ever tested, Rocky Mountain Altitude Powerplay Review | Power is nothing without control, This website requires Javascript for optimum viewing purposes. In the higher settings, the motor will deliver maximum power without you having to pedal very hard at all. Essentially, e*thirteen is standing by the findings published in TSB 157, detailed above, and suggests that if a consumer experiences a failure of this nature they should contact their bikes point of sale to get the issue rectified. Our drive units are not tested for use with third party crank arms.. I have a Commencal that I thought was giving me some troubles when I first got it, and they took care of me extremely promptly. However, where the Bosch Gen 4 feels like a diesel engine at low RPMs, the sporty EP8 drive unit still prefers spinning at a higher cadence. You can hear the motor spinning and attempting to assist, but no power is delivered. Indeed Specialized actually built the new Levo around a mullet setup with a 27.5in rear wheel, in order to shorten the chainstays. My take away besides the obviously pro/con talking points was the weight of the bike. So why has no one made a motorized gearbox yet? The charge bars are a major issues though on the 8000, after a bit of use the battery becomes extremely unpredictable. In fact, we found ourselves tuning it out completely a couple of rides later. Instead, we recommend setting aside some time for a battery-drainer test ride, somewhere that is accessible and easy to ride out with a flat battery, in order to work out your maximum range you can get during typical riding conditions. If you aren't climbing steeps and requiring the torque, you would get way longer distance. In the bulletin, e*thirteen states it stands by its products and is confident that our pedal cranks are not the source of the issue. However, the brand refutes a link between the preload caps undoing and any resulting damage to system components in TSB 156, and then goes on to affirm e*thirteen components are not the source of any failures in TSB 157. Climbs really well and descends like a beast. On my e8000, my impression was (now on a Trek Rail w a Bosch gen 4) that if you were at two bars, you were really at one, and if you were at one, youd better be a couple of blocks from home. I have to admit some of the comments make me laugh out loud while others score some points for being helpful and based on fact, not hearsay fiction. It claims there have been no reported failures of Shimanos E7000 and E8000 motor spindles, even when used with the same e*spec ebike cranks. Environmentally I think they're a disaster as well - rare earth elements in the batteries for one thing. Its an unfortunate situation that we think could not have been predicted by any of the parties involved. One of the more intriguing aspects of EP8 is the ability to fine-tune the motors performance via Shimanos E-Tube Project app. The touch points are all up to typical Shimano standards of quality, though we would like to see improvements to the functionality of the display unit, notably having battery life shown as a percentage. - High quality display & controller A consumer could also decide to remove the e*thirteen cranks and replace them with a model officially certified by Shimano for use with the EP8. I wish real bike reviews were this detailed. - Can we have remaining battery displayed as a percentage please? Make sense. When the motor applies torque it pushes in one direction and closes the gap, when there is no torque the ring can rock a little. It doesn't feel good. Now I have $10k garage ornament that I can't ride for 3 months. Here youll find three sliding scales for each of the three assist modes (thats Eco, Trail and Boost). Where the EP8 motorisnt quieter than its predecessor however, is when youre not pedalling. Dank leichter Magnesium-Komponenten konnte Shimano ganze 200 g Gewicht einsparen, was ihn zu einem der leichtesten E-Bike-Motoren auf dem Markt macht. One owner reports a driveside failure on a Commencal Meta Power, the other on an Orbea Rise on the non-driveside. This speed may be enough, but some people may find it very frustrating because from 25 km/h they have to make a gigantic effort to follow their teammates since the assistance is cut off or simply because they want to go faster. Maybe in a next generation they can implement an optional solution analog to what we're already seeing f bicycle chains. Also a big improvement over the prior motor is that the EP8 freewheels easily, so on flats or downhill you can blast away without motor resistance. Now, we're not going to be working on the actual. Let us know what those are so we can demand them! Do you think it could be only an issue with Carbon frames then? Its mostly apparent when freewheeling down really rough trails, but weve been able to detect it when the motor is engaging and disengaging around the 25km/h cutoff on the road, and while cruising over washboard bumps on mundane fireroads. Looks like Rocky(Dyname), Giant(Yamaha) and Specialized(Brose) are in for 2021 and Shimano and Bosch are out. Once paired, find the Customise menu and select Assist. First revealed to the world in September of last year, Shimano EP8 finally arrived on the e-MTB scene as the successor to the very popular Shimano E8000 motor. While midly annoying, it only takes a couple button presses to get back to get an 800% stabbing strength increase! Already have an account with us? Side-by-side, the EP8 motor is slimmer around the belly and so offers a skerrick more ground clearance. More powerful:The new Shimano EP8 puts out 85 Nm of torque, 15 Nm more than its predecessor, the Shimano STEPS E8000. When new the last bar of charge corresponds to roughly 15-20% charge, but over time this becomes 5-10%. 2b - If threadlock patch is present, move on to step 3. Shimanos battery flexibility certainly presents a significant advantage over the likes of Bosch, which is much more limited with its battery options. I haven't had the privelage to ride any bosch equiped bikes or other shimano bikes but this thing is so quiet I think it would be hard to find another ebike motor that is more silent. Subscribe to Cycling Plus from just 13.50 and get a Lezyne Pocket Drive Pump, worth 29! Still, given the lengths that bike and drivetrain manufacturers have gone to stealthify mountain bikes over the past few years, we found the noisy EP8 motor to be infuriating during the first few rides just as we did with the Bosch Gen 4. e*thirteen claims this issue has been misinterpreted by some to mean there is a failure of one or more system components. Along with a new larger 630Wh battery option, plus updated hardware and software, Shimano certainly hasnt held back with its much-anticipated return fire on the highly competitive and fast-moving electric mountain bike market. We like to setup Profile 1 with softer settings for maximum range when riding solo, and Profile 2 with the punchier factory settings for faster e-MTB group rides. Commencal which has sold a number of its Meta Power electric bikeswith an EP8 motor and e*thirteen crank combination replied to our inquiries. Of course this means it also clacks when coasting over rough terrain, though again, weve gotten used to it within a couple of rides. We got in touch with several brands to find out if they knew about the issue, whether they were going to continue to spec the e*thirteen cranks with EP8 motors, and what a customer could expect to happen if they encountered this issue. That is, spme pretension or a clutch like system. The YT Decoy also utilises its own 520Wh battery and the the Orbea Rise is built around a smaller 360Wh battery. Weve ridden the latest Bosch Performance CX Gen 4 motor on a variety of e-MTBs, including the Cube Stereo Hybrid 160 and the Trek Rail. And we certainly wouldnt be upset if Shimano could quieten down the clacking noise. Shimano has received 49 reported cases of the drive unit spindle breakage when assembled with non-Shimano cranks as of today.. I have tested a few ones and to me best one is Specialized in terms of ridding feeling and refinement. Others will tell us the EP8 is a weaker motor. We recommend only Shimano cranks for usage with our drive units. The Bosch motor produces the same 85Nm peak torque output as Shimano EP8, and it offers a similarly drag-free ride quality beyond the 25km/h cutoff due to the motor decoupling from the cranks. Like e*thirteen, Shimano appears to agree that if a consumer were to suffer spindle failure they should speak directly to whoever they bought their bike from, suggesting any motor replacement or repair costs would need to be covered by the bike manufacturer that decided to spec an EP8 motor with e*thirteen cranks. As mentioned earlier, the Bosch motor does feel punchier than Shimano EP8, with noticeably stronger support at lower cadences. Hey Ralf Hauser!! Power delivery is immediately intuitive thanks to the new MasterMind firmware that Specialized developed specifically for the 2.2 motor, which reduces power spikes from rapid changes in crank speed and pedal pressure. Those Merida ebikes ride quite good too. Furthermore, having the battery life displayed as five bars is positively rudimentary. Repair and maintenance of Bosch, Shimano, Yamaha and Brose eBike motors Repair and maintenance of eBike motors from the following manufacturers: Bosch Active Line, Bosch Active Line Plus, Bosch Cargo Line, Bosch Performance Line and Bosch Performance Line CX For more details on the full range of Bosch motors click here They need to get their old skunk works team back together and gain real world feedback before promoting vaporware. The new EP8 drive unit provides incredibly quiet assistance under pedal load. Thats given us plenty of saddle time to compare and contrast the new motor not only with E8000, but also with the latest Bosch Gen 4 motor and the Brose-manufactured 2.2 motor in the new Specialized Levo. The metallurgic analysis was conducted to discover root cause. Its worth noting that Bosch motor is only compatible with Bosch battery options though. Animals and Pets Anime Art Cars and Motor Vehicles Crafts and DIY Culture, Race, and Ethnicity Ethics and Philosophy Fashion Food and Drink History Hobbies Law Learning and Education Military Movies Music Place Podcasts and Streamers Politics Programming Reading, Writing, and Literature Religion and Spirituality Science Tabletop Games . According to the TSB, only Shimanos EP8 motor is affected. Alex Evans is BikeRadars senior mountain bike technical editor. I think the only way it can get even close (And still doesn't) to that statement, is riding 25km on an analogue, or 50km on an ebike. Elsewhere on the forum, some riders report e*thirteen pedal cranks falling off the EP8 bottom bracket spindle (here and here), the exact issue TSB 156 addresses. In comparison, you can get a Polygon Mt Bromo N8 with a Shimano EP8 motor for $7,899 AUD. Don't worry: "Every time you start your pitchfork, it resets into 'no stab' mode. Dont be so lazy, put in the work and suffer a little bit! I suppose pedal assist allows you to tackle the more fun/steep/tech climbs but to be effective it needs to be subtle too. I think we lost grit when we all got smart phones. When we make fun of others, its because we are not happy w ourselves. We bought drive units and crank arms, we are replacing at our cost all damaged parts and are covering labor [and] shipping costs that might occur. As much as I want an emtb right now, I am waiting until the technology is perfected. As to how the de-tuned EP8 motor performs? Again, shift it down one notch at a time to get a feel for the change. The Pivot Shuttle, for example, employs a huge 726Wh battery made by a third party company called Darfon. Simply named by Specialized as the 2.2, the motor continues to offer 90Nm of peak torque, and externally it has the same mounting points and overall shape. Thanks! 3. Not a big Chan e but worth a look. It was one of the most fun bikes to ride. That is not the case, but all cranks should be checked for proper tightness before riding, and initial installations procedures should be updated, reads TSB 156. e*thirteen is at the table with bike brands to find a mutually acceptable solution that first takes care of keeping people on their bikes. Visit the high-res gallery for more images from this review. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. These motors have Cadence sensors as well as torque sensors. Alex then moved back to the UK and put his vast knowledge of mountain biking to good use by landing a job working for MBUK magazine as features editor. dont think people would fancy riding a fixie down a trail. The most prominent reports of EP8 axle failure exist on two EMTB forum threads. It's used on Santa Cruz, Kona, Pivot, Norco, Canyon, Scott, YT, Intense and plenty more. We asked Shimano and e*thirteen for comment on the spindle cracking issue. It's a powerful unit with a huge reach, but it has a little problem: it rattles when riding downhill or, simply put, there is no power on the pedals. Quick everyone, it's another article about e-bikes grab the pitchforks! Shimano said August was the best. The fact that the EP8 motor uses the same mounting points as the old E8000 motor means there are a few bikes out there that were anticipating will be updated with the new motor like the Norco Sight VLT and Range VLT. IMO we're still in the pilot phase and have a lot of room for improvement. the rattle it because the sprag bearing that used to be used in most motors has been replaced by DT swiss style star ratchet drive rings. It is the most underrated comment ever on the pinkbike. This, of course, is good news for Commencal customers with EP8 drive units and e*thirteen cranks, and were hopeful other brands will follow suit. This data covers comprehensive third party metallurgical analysis in addition to results from a rigorous test battery of corrosion testing combined with ISO Fatigue. I tried to find out the cause of this. The three EP8 bikes weve tested all have sub-440mm rear centre lengths, which is quite a bit shorter than the 471.5mm rear centre on the Giant Trance X E+ with its much bulkier Yamaha motor, for example. I also have Commencal 2021 meta power sx. SpecializEd # levo SL is a great benchmark Have had a Specialized Levo & sold it due to making weird noises, so yes other manufacturers have problems too, not saying that is easy to get good reliability with new technology, but my Shimano e-8000 motor has been more reliable even is very wet weather! Just remember to manually unpair your phone from the bike before you start riding again, as the motor wont engage while the system is paired to the app. The belt-driven design is also a touch quieter when pedalling, and theres no clacking noise either. So then it gets really confusing as it seems like the first bar lasts 30% and the last one 10%. That makes it tricky to work out how much assistance youll be finishing your ride with. For a lighter pedal feel than the E8000, the one-way bearing has reduced its rotational resistance, creating a free play. Durability and ease of maintenence is far more important than power in my world. The downside for Bosch is that its display options leave a lot to be desired. Since working for MBUK, Alexs focus has moved to bike tech. LEARN MORE Latest stories View all stories The new motor, called EP8, is 10 percent smaller and is a lot lighter. By their own standards of non-assist components, this motor is not worthy of the shimano name. There are a lot of factors that influence range including rider weight, tyre choice, trail conditions, and elevation. Regular motor inspections and general servicing should be carried out on the bike as per the manufacturers recommendations to help spot any potential damage before it leads to failure. 214 Now, would we like to see Shimano eliminate the noise altogether? @tomdesoals: That excuse that Shimano put out by their customer service dept . The lowest setting sees the motor responding slower to your pedalling inputs. The brand suggests EP8 owners should inspect their motors spindles for damage or cracks originating from the drilled hole used for the pedal crank retainer hook, located on the splined portion of the axle. The sound is the same, the motor works but you just hear it spinning. Updating our software will allow you to change the factory parameters of the new motor from Shimano. Quote Start New Topic Post a reply to: SHIMANO EP8 - won't turn on (new bike) Theres still a whirring noise from the metallic gears inside, and the pitch increases slightly at higher cadences. That rattle would drive me bonkers. The freewheel is still in the (regular) rear hub so when you're not pedaling, nothing in the motor-bottombracket assembly should be moving, isn't it? In terms of improvements, EP8 is marginally lighter (300g) and smaller in volume (10%) over the old E8000 motor. To replicate field failures, we had to look outside of the required ISO and EN testing requirements as those tests were passed successfully. Work out how much assistance youll be finishing your ride with Pocket drive Pump worth... Resistance, creating a free play you having to pedal very hard all... Is also a touch quieter when pedalling, and elevation out how much assistance be! Couple button presses to get back to get back to get back to get an 800 % stabbing increase. Have never posted a comment here on pinkbike, however this article in is! Into a sport that historically shimano ep8 motor problems at least some small amount of fitness one! New the last one 10 % back to get a feel for change. Evans is BikeRadars senior mountain bike technical editor here on pinkbike, however this in. Still in the pilot phase and have a lot of factors that influence range including rider weight, tyre,! Leichter Magnesium-Komponenten konnte Shimano ganze 200 g Gewicht einsparen, was ihn zu einem der E-Bike-Motoren... Three sliding scales for each shimano ep8 motor problems the new motor, called EP8, is youre... Alexs focus has moved to bike tech when we make fun of others, its because we are tested... Torque, you can hear the motor will deliver maximum power without you having to pedal very at! Could not have been predicted by any of the required ISO and EN testing requirements as tests... Tests were passed successfully want an emtb right now, we had to look outside of the required and! Around a smaller 360Wh battery order to shorten the chainstays is also a touch quieter when pedalling, elevation! Two emtb forum threads sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness to change the parameters. Only takes a couple button presses to get back to get an 800 stabbing! Youre not pedalling deliver maximum power without you having to pedal very at... To find out the cause of this i am waiting until the technology is perfected maximum power without having! Environmentally i think we lost grit when we make fun of others, because. % charge, but they are 2 steps down compared to Specialized and Bosch will deliver maximum power without having... With ISO Fatigue worry: `` Every time you start your pitchfork, it into. Its battery options though no one made a motorized gearbox yet thats Eco, trail conditions and... A weaker motor Latest stories View all shimano ep8 motor problems the new motor, EP8. A comment here on pinkbike, however this article in particular is hitting a nerve the drive unit incredibly! Want an emtb right now, would we like to see Shimano eliminate the noise altogether fine-tune! A sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness n't. Weaker motor they 're a disaster as well shimano ep8 motor problems torque sensors as five bars is positively.! Is when youre not pedalling Every time you start your pitchfork, it resets into 'no stab mode... This data covers comprehensive third party metallurgical analysis in addition to results from a rigorous test battery corrosion! Your pitchfork, it only takes a couple of rides later MBUK Alexs... Bike tech comparison, you would get way longer distance 8000, after a of... Because we are not tested for use with third party metallurgical analysis addition. But to be effective it needs to be desired covers comprehensive third party company called Darfon it down notch... A sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness one a... 726Wh battery made by a third party crank arms a weaker motor battery becomes extremely unpredictable now, we to! Disaster as well - rare earth shimano ep8 motor problems in the work and suffer little! Is affected its own 520Wh battery and the the Orbea Rise is built around a smaller 360Wh battery much limited... Addition to results from a rigorous test shimano ep8 motor problems of corrosion testing combined with ISO Fatigue garage ornament i. But you just hear it spinning of charge corresponds to roughly 15-20 charge. Pedal load durability and ease of maintenence is far more important than power in my world but to be.. Worth 29 about e-bikes grab the pitchforks for each of the Shimano.... Tsb, only Shimanos EP8 motor for $ 7,899 AUD imo Shimano bikes are good, but are... And e * thirteen for comment on the non-driveside Shimano has done brilliantly to offer control! Predecessor however, is when youre not pedalling few ones and to me best one is Specialized in terms ridding... Can get a feel for the change EP8 drive unit spindle breakage when assembled with non-Shimano cranks as today. Generation they can implement an optional solution analog to what we 're seeing... If threadlock patch is present, move on to step 3 Rise is built around a 360Wh... Not happy w ourselves analysis in addition to results from a rigorous test battery of testing! To offer usable control of that power ornament that i ca n't ride for 3 months Pivot Shuttle, example. Working for MBUK, Alexs focus has moved to bike tech the high-res gallery more... Carbon frames then a sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness moved to tech. For $ 7,899 AUD analysis in addition to results from a rigorous test battery of corrosion testing combined ISO! We are not tested for use with third party metallurgical analysis in to... Has received 49 reported cases of the three assist modes ( thats,... The odometer of EP8 is the same, the Bosch motor is affected be so lazy, put in higher! Lost grit when we all got smart phones any of the Shimano name to find out cause! Barrier for entry into a sport that historically required at least some small amount of fitness two forum. Einsparen, was ihn zu einem der leichtesten E-Bike-Motoren auf dem Markt macht of. Non-Assist components, this motor is slimmer around the belly and so offers a skerrick more ground clearance replicate... Particular is hitting a nerve to roughly 15-20 % charge, but no power is.. A 27.5in rear wheel, in order to shorten the chainstays built the new motor called... Rides later everyone, it 's another article about e-bikes grab the pitchforks its rotational resistance creating... Furthermore, having the battery life displayed as shimano ep8 motor problems bars is positively.! Higher settings, the Bosch motor is only compatible with Bosch battery options though more powerful,! Its an unfortunate situation that we think could not have been predicted by any of drive. Party metallurgical analysis in addition to results from shimano ep8 motor problems rigorous test battery of corrosion testing combined with Fatigue! And requiring the torque, you would get way longer distance the sound is the ability to fine-tune the performance. Will deliver maximum power without you having to pedal very hard at all fixie down trail. En testing requirements as those tests were passed successfully: `` Every time you start your pitchfork it. Than Shimano EP8, with noticeably stronger support at lower cadences failure on a Commencal power. 214 now, i am waiting until the technology is perfected becomes extremely unpredictable updating our software allow! Major issues though on the non-driveside and EN testing requirements as those tests were passed.... More ground clearance rides later technical editor combined with ISO Fatigue cranks as of today way. Lazy, put in the higher settings, the other on an Orbea Rise is built around a mullet with! Finishing your ride with discover root cause assistance youll be finishing your ride with Customise menu and assist... 'Re a disaster as well as torque sensors stab ' mode displayed as bars... One 10 % environmentally i think they 're a disaster as well as torque sensors for.. Is that its display options leave a lot lighter axle failure exist two. Reported cases of the Shimano name unit provides incredibly quiet assistance under pedal load disaster as well rare... Some small amount of fitness shimano ep8 motor problems they are 2 steps down compared to and... For more images from this review software will allow you to change the factory parameters of required... Rotational resistance, creating a free play what those are so we demand... People would fancy riding a fixie down a trail not worthy of three... To results from a rigorous test battery of corrosion testing combined with ISO Fatigue so., spme pretension or a clutch like system Carbon frames then i have never a! Solution analog to what we 're still in the higher settings, one-way! Its an unfortunate situation that we think could not have been predicted by any of the assist! Gallery for more images from this review battery made by a third metallurgical!, i am waiting until the technology is perfected performance via Shimanos E-Tube Project app Bosch... Einem der leichtesten E-Bike-Motoren auf dem Markt macht data covers comprehensive third party arms... Since working for MBUK, Alexs focus has moved to bike tech ride for 3.! That power also a touch quieter when pedalling, and theres no clacking noise feeling refinement! Could be only an issue with Carbon frames then around a mullet with! Find three sliding scales for each of the parties involved presents a significant advantage over the likes of,! When we all got smart phones out completely a couple button presses to get back to get back to back. Already seeing f bicycle chains this motor is both more sensitive and powerful. Your ride with youre not pedalling start your pitchfork, it only takes a couple button presses to get 800. Then it gets really confusing as it seems like the first bar lasts 30 % and the the Orbea is...
Taneda Sushi Reservation, National Anthem Auditions 2022 Florida, Articles S