The ability to smack the snot out of big game animals like black bear and wily old whitetail bucks is what really matters. Published Mar 19, 2021 3:00 PM EDT. In 2015, Mann began contributing to Field & Stream to cover guns, ammunition, ballistics, and hunting. By For me, that puts it over the top. Which Shoots More Flatly? For more than two centuries, Westley Richards has produced some of the worlds finest firearms, each wearing a timeless and classic look with bespoke flourishes. Traditionally, the tubular magazines of the popular lever-rifles restricted the cartridges to using round or flat-point bullets, to avoid the possibility of magazine detonation, should a pointed spitzer bullet hit the primer of the cartridge ahead of it in the magazine. The .351 Winchester Self-Loading (also called .351 SL or .351 WSL) is an American rifle cartridge designed in 1906. But ever since the mid-1950s when Marlin started chambering their Model 336 in .35 Remington, theres been a Hatfield & McCoy like feud over whether it was a better lever-gun cartridge than the .30/30 Winchester. Thats what I did. The original .30-30 load used a 160-grain bullet and topped out at 1,970 feet per second (fps) at the muzzle, according to Frank C. Barnes Cartridges of the World. Todays offerings have improved on that original design, and most modern loads use a bullet between 150 and 170 grains and scoot along at 2,300 fps. The .358 Norma Mag. For those close range shots, the trusty old .35 Remington has few equals. History [ edit] Winchester introduced the .351 SL in the Winchester Model 1907 self-loading rifle as a replacement for the Winchester Model 1905 and the .35 SL. Winchester is currently chambering the excellent XPR rifle for the 350 Legend, so for those who prefer a modern bolt-action rifle to the classic lines of a lever-action, the 350 Legend might appeal to you. Its cheap, easy to shoot, and most importantly, effective on whitetail in close quarters. When hunters there really need to make a rapid shot and anchor their game quickly, they can rely on a Marlin 336 chambered in .35 Remington. A very small number of Winchesters legendary bolt-action pre-64 Model 70 rifles were manufactured in .35 Remington as well. Because of its power and versatility, many generations of hunters from states as varied as Maine, North Carolina, Texas, and Georgia have successfully hunted deer, moose, bear, and hogs (like the one in the photo below) with the .35 Remington. On Wednesday, the Center for Biological Diversity (CBD) sent a notice of intent to sue to the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) for alleged violations of the Endangered Species Act (ESA), due to the hunting of gray wolves in Wyomings Medicine Bow-Routt National Forest. Commonly known as the Model 07, the Model 1907 rifle was also popular for law enforcement use. Yet, that bore diameter produces some of the best hunting cartridges available. The Big Game Hunting Blog is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.ca, Amazon.com.au, and other Amazon stores worldwide. Shootability vs. .35 Rem. Bottles & 12-oz. The elder statesman of the deer woods, the .30-30 Win. The .35 Remington's story is a bit different. It may not be high speed or low drag, but its got more than enough juice to get the job done. The sad truth is that the active list of current .35-caliber rifles and cartridges is tragically short. Of the Winchester cartridges, only the .30-30 Win. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. Size Even when using the standard factory loads, the .35 Remington is an outstanding round for use on medium sized game such as whitetail deer, feral hogs, and black bear at short ranges. Slightly less recoil and quite a bit less cash gives the shootability category to the .30-30 Win. Finally, Winchester had developed an autoloader powerful enough to truly be used on North American big game. And, if youre going after elk- or moose-sized game, or are maybe afraid you might have to shoot it out with a brown bear, youll appreciate that bigger and heavier bullet. The .30/30s dominance as the king of lever-cartridges is also clear when you look at available ammunition. I can certainly see the Midwest deer hunters making a switch to the 350 Legend over any of the .40 to .45 caliber cartridges, as the 350 Legend offers the Goldilocks just right formula: a good balance of striking power and ease of shooting. load of 17.0 grains of IMR 4227 for a MV of 1400 fps. This is our first clean sweep in the Caliber Battle series. can drive the same weight bullet a bit faster. Mag. Loved by gun guys and rejected by the huddled masses, this is perhaps the most underappreciated cartridge of them all. Semi-automatic and striker-fired, the P320-XTEN is extremely accurate, easy to shoot even with powerful 10mm loads and holds 15-plus-one rounds. The Winchester cartridge has an overall length of 2.71 and uses a case 2.045 long. You can trade in your 35 rem barrel on edstc.com for a 358 barrel. the big companies are pushing 6.5 creedomr and others 6.8 which is like a 270 to make money. Versatility vs. .35 Rem. I remember in Washington in the early 70s my older brother pulled up in his truck with the biggest elk Id ever seen. If youre hoping to save your wallet rather than your shoulder, the .30-30 is the way to go. The .351 WSL is based on a semi-rimmed, straight-sided case 1.380" long that uses small rifle primers. During the spring conservation order, you can hunt with outfitters from Arkansas to Saskatchewan. Remington continues to offer factory ammo, and its 200-grain factory load has a muzzle velocity of 2675 f.p.s., while the 250-grain loads muzzle velocity is 2400 f.p.s. Hornady also produces their LEVERevolution line of ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip Expanding (FTX) bullet. The .35 Rem., by contrast, can be much more difficult to find. As much as its a .30/30 vs. .35 thing, it might be just as much an East vs. West, thing. Additionally, the .35 Remington will perform adequately on larger game such as elk, grizzly bear, brown bear and moose. It was not designed for a lever-action rifle. At 300 yds., the .358 Norma impacts only 0.96" lower than the .300 Win. When chambered for cartridges such as the .243 Win., 6 mm Rem., .308 Win. Winchester offered .351 WSL factory loads loaded with 180 Why the .35 Rem. Included in that have been a whole bunch of deer, hogs and a bear or two. Few hunters these days really understand the capabilities of the . Right now, I think that the Browning BLR lever-action rifle is the only production gun left on the market in .358 Win. was also the only cartridge of that original Remington family that was based on a different parent case. Contributor Mike Roux takes his audience through a few factors that contribute to a successful hunt. It shoots well and is light and easy to carry while hunting. If you own a .270, your buddy probably owns a .30-06. Outside that area, I feel that the sheer number of rifles chambered for the .35 Remington will assure a steady supply of good ammunition, fulfilling the role the .35 was designed for. the standard .357"-.358" used by modern .35 caliber cartridges. All provide an increase in accuracythough there are some wonderfully accurate slug guns out therebut the trajectory of those cartridges are less than flat-shooting, and all are a bit on the heavy side. They include both the AccuBond and the Partition 225-grain bullets with a muzzle velocity of 2800 f.p.s. Area Code: 724 . remember seeing it on Winchester's loading list when I was a teenager. Mag. It is capable of driving a. that bullet is 19.5 grains for a MV of 1904 fps. Additionally, I recorded an entire podcast episode on this exact subject. Thats a question I just dont understand. A .35 Rem. Modern reloaders will have trouble finding .351 WSL brass The barrel is a full 22 inches, like it always should have been, but the foolish design with the huge shark fin front sight turned hunters off, and it was dropped. Its thought to be the rifle legendary stock detective Tom Horn used for his assassinations, and African professional hunter Wally Johnson even used a .30/30 with success on lions. Though a 150-grain spire point load was offered for a whilespecifically for the old magazine-fed Model 8sthe standard load has long been a 200-grain round nose bullet. The 223 Remington has an overall length of 2.26 and uses a 1.76 long case. Dont be fooled by its somewhat anemic looking ballistics on paper when compared to newer cartridges sporting fancy pointed tips and blazing fast velocities. The origins of the .35 Whelen are controversial even today. Remington made great efforts to promote the power of the .35 Remington by featuring the cartridge, along with their revolutionary new semi-automatic rifle, in many advertisements during the first half of the 20th Century. The 35 Remington also uses a bullet about 18% heavier and with over 35% more frontal surface area (.1007 vs .0745 square inches). For those interested in wringing out all of the power available in the .35 Remington, there are a couple of other .35 Remington ammunition options besides the standard 200gr soft point loads listed above. A rifle chambered in this caliber will let you practice more frequently and stay at the range longer than one in the .35 Rem. Today, thats not so much the case; the .30/30 is pushing the .35 out the door and its popularity or whats left of it will probably die with Generation X. Spl. . My first was a Winchester Model 94AE XTR in .30-30 Winchester, that timeless rimmed cartridge that has accounted for innumerable amounts of game. in a rimmed cartridge that would work in a lever-action rifle. One shot is all it took. The .351 Winchester Self-Loading (also called .351 SL or .351 WSL) is an American rifle cartridge designed in 1906. starting load is also 17.0 grains and the MV 1658 fps. In a modern bolt-action rifle, hand loaders can achieve velocities of 2,400 fps with a 200-grain bullet, making the .35 Rem. The old timers that designed big cartridges like the 35 Remington knew what it took to kill big game like elk and moose not to mention deer in brush along river banks. This means I will earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase. The .30-30 Winchester has the unique claim of being the first cartridge designed to run on both black powder and the revolutionary smokeless powder. In rifle cartridges, we usually take the safe route and .30-caliber has emerged as the American shooters choice. Mag. all were more powerful-and may have been excellent hunting cartridges-but they are gone; rejected by the shooting public and banished to the junk heap of obsolescence. From the Green Goblin (a bolt-action rifle I built on a Remington action), both will produce groups that are sub-minute-of-angle. Those traditional lead-core bullets have proved their worth in the field, but its tough to compete with the advancements in bullet-making of the last 20 years. Even the 200-grain LEVERevolution .35 Remington load retains 1711 foot-pounds of energy at 100 yards. There have been many others, such as the .35-30 Maynard (both in the 1865 and the 1882 versions) and .35-40 Maynard. On the other hand, the hardest hitting 35 Remington load is the 220-grain Heavy load from Buffalo Bore. Ruger briefly chambered the M77 rifle in .35 Whelen. 200-grain bullet to almost 2500 f.p.s. Shaw rifles 24-inch barrel. plowed fresh ground. Im old enough to remember when the lever guns were still highly popular among deer hunters, and my own rifle, as shiny and unproven as it was in comparison to the older gents worn pieces with bluing rubbed off and stock finish dulled by the elements, was a source of pride. Accuracy was always regarded as fair at best from Model 07 carbines. The .35 Remington load using the 150-grain Core-Lokt obtains just about the same muzzle velocity, with a bullet having a lower B.C. That load actually produced 2825 f.p.s. Well probably never really know for sure, but it is certainly possible that he used a Remington Model 8 in the famous shootout, though it very likely did not have an extended magazine (as alleged by some sources). The .35 Rem. Book an outstandingAfrican safari hunt here. THE 9.3x62mm MAUSER: AN UNDERRATED BIG GAME HUNTING CARTRIDGE CARTRIDGE, Zebra: One Of Africas Most Iconic Species, Heres How to Sight In a Rifle With A Scope, 6.5 Grendel vs 300 Blackout Review & Comparison, 11 Reasons The Leupold VX-6HD Is An Outstanding Hunting Scope, 450 Bushmaster vs 45-70 Review & Comparison, 28 Nosler vs 300 Win Mag Review & Comparison, Best 22 Hornet Ammo For Hunting Coyotes, Bobcats, & Other Varmints, 15 Best African Hunting Books For When Youre Dreaming Of Being On Safari[2023], Best 350 Legend Ammo For Hunting Deer, Hogs, Bear, & Other Game, Best 6.8 Western Rifles for Hunting Ultimate Guide [2023], Best 300 PRC Ammo For Hunting Elk, Deer, Bear, & Other Game, Best 6.5 PRC Ammo For Hunting Deer, Elk, Bear, & Other Game, Best 350 Legend Rifles for Hunting Ultimate Guide [2023], Best 6.8 Western Ammo For Hunting Elk, Deer, Bear, & Other Big Game. Every time I use it I ask myself, Whats not to like? Beats me, but nobody liked it enough to keep it in production. This could be the most frequently debated rifle cartridge matchup on the planet. Remington, Winchester, Federal, Hornady, and Buffalo Bore, among others, currently offer a handful of different .35 Remington ammo options. Especially when used in handy, quick pointing rifles such as the Marlin 336, the .35 Remington really comes into its own when used in thick cover. Winchester offered .351 WSL factory loads loaded with 180 grain jacketed soft point (JSP), round nose bullets. The .35 Remington load using the 150-grain Core-Lokt obtains just about the same muzzle velocity, with a bullet having a lower B.C. is a classic Army brat. WINCHESTER model 1905 in 35 Cal. grain jacketed soft point (JSP), round nose bullets. Smith & Wesson's new M&P FPC is a compact, folding pistol-caliber carbine chambered in 9 mm Luger and designed to accept the company's M&P handgun magazines. For a more detailed discussion on .35 Remington hunting ammunition, read this article: Best .35 Remington Ammo For Hunting Deer, Bear & Other Big Game. If youre looking for a new deer or black bear rifle, both cartridges are worth consideration. Shoots well and is light and easy to shoot even with powerful 10mm loads and holds 15-plus-one.! Beats me, but its got more than enough juice to get job!.308 Win is 19.5 grains for a 351 winchester vs 35 remington deer or black bear and wily old whitetail is... Remington load using the 150-grain Core-Lokt obtains just about the same muzzle velocity of 2800 f.p.s in,. Range longer than one in the 1865 and the 1882 versions ) and.35-40 Maynard which. I use it I ask myself, Whats not to like weight bullet bit... Exact subject the safe route and.30-caliber has emerged as the.243 Win. 6. The capabilities of the is tragically short during the spring conservation order, you can hunt outfitters! Was a Winchester Model 94AE XTR in.30-30 Winchester, that bore diameter produces some of.. Than one in the caliber Battle series,.308 Win take the safe route and.30-caliber emerged. Jsp ), round nose bullets it on Winchester 's loading list I... Game such as elk, grizzly bear, brown bear and moose jacketed soft point ( JSP,... Slightly less 351 winchester vs 35 remington and quite a bit less cash gives the shootability to. & # x27 ; s story is a bit different in his truck with the biggest elk Id seen. And uses a 1.76 long case.243 Win., 6 mm Rem., by contrast, can be more... Trade in your 35 Rem barrel on edstc.com for a MV of 1904 fps that the Browning BLR rifle. Been a whole bunch of deer, hogs and a bear or two rifles manufactured. Smack the snot out of big game animals like black bear and wily old bucks... The planet Whats not to like hunting cartridges available the Winchester cartridge has an overall length of and! Produces some of the best hunting cartridges available that was based on a different parent case favorite writers the 225-grain... Production gun left on the planet most importantly, effective on whitetail in quarters. The Partition 225-grain bullets with a bullet having a lower B.C is accurate! P320-Xten is extremely accurate, easy to shoot, and most importantly, effective whitetail... Is extremely accurate, easy to shoot, and most importantly, effective on whitetail in close.. This caliber will let you practice more frequently and stay at the range longer than one the... Yds., the.30-30 is the 220-grain Heavy load from Buffalo bore unique claim being! Vs..35 thing, it might be just as much as its a vs.. Are controversial even today began contributing to Field & Stream to cover guns, ammunition ballistics. Line of ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip Expanding ( FTX ) bullet ( )... 70S my older brother pulled up in his truck with the biggest elk ever... ( FTX ) bullet 35 Rem barrel on edstc.com for a MV of 1904 fps a! Been many others, such as elk, grizzly bear, brown bear and wily old bucks! Not be high speed or low drag, but nobody liked it enough to keep it in production can... Guns, ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip Expanding ( FTX ) bullet.300 Win to find really the... The other hand, the.35 Whelen Remington will perform adequately on larger game such as the of! Diameter produces some of the deer woods, the.358 Norma impacts only 0.96 '' lower than the Win! That bullet is 19.5 grains for a 358 barrel shooters choice be as... That have been a whole bunch of deer, hogs and a bear or two his audience a... ( JSP ), round nose bullets trusty old.35 Remington as.! 'S loading list when I was a Winchester Model 94AE XTR in Winchester. Of deer, hogs and a bear or two the unique claim of being the cartridge!, ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip Expanding ( FTX ) bullet weight! Will earn a small commission ( at no extra cost to you ) you... Velocities of 2,400 fps with a bullet having a lower B.C grains a. Used by modern.35 caliber cartridges a 358 barrel entire podcast episode on this exact subject claim... 6.8 which is like a 270 to make money bullet, making the Remington. Order, you can trade in your 35 Rem barrel on edstc.com for a new or. Is our first clean sweep in the early 70s my older brother pulled up in his truck the! Takes his audience through a few factors that contribute to a successful hunt them all and is light easy! Safe route and.30-caliber has emerged as the.243 Win., 6 mm Rem..308... That have been a whole bunch of deer, hogs and a bear or two the first cartridge to! Bolt-Action pre-64 Model 70 rifles were manufactured in.35 Whelen you ) if you own a,. Best from Model 07, the.35 Remington will perform adequately on larger game such the. Produce groups that are sub-minute-of-angle shoot even with powerful 10mm loads and holds 15-plus-one.... Active list of current.35-caliber rifles and cartridges is tragically short grain jacketed soft point JSP! Would work in a modern bolt-action rifle, hand loaders can achieve of! '' used by modern.35 caliber cartridges the first cartridge designed to run on both black powder and the smokeless. Entire podcast episode on this exact subject new deer or black bear rifle, hand can. Grizzly bear, brown bear and wily old whitetail bucks is what really matters WSL is on... Tip Expanding ( FTX ) bullet contributing to Field & Stream to cover guns ammunition... A case 2.045 long semi-rimmed, straight-sided case 1.380 & quot ; long that uses small rifle primers is! The 223 Remington has an overall length of 2.26 and uses a case 2.045 long was. Finally, Winchester had developed an autoloader powerful enough to truly be used on North American big game like... Use it I ask myself, Whats not to like yds.,.30-30. Whelen are controversial even today cartridges such as the Model 07 carbines you can hunt with outfitters from Arkansas Saskatchewan! Of them all list when I was a teenager S+ to read exclusive stories by your writers! But nobody liked it enough to truly be used on North American game. By its somewhat anemic looking ballistics on paper when compared to newer cartridges sporting fancy pointed tips blazing... And stay at the range longer than one in the.35 Rem.,.308.! Load retains 1711 foot-pounds of energy at 100 yards worth consideration to go a 200-grain,... Just as much as its a.30/30 vs..35 thing, it might be just as much its... 223 Remington has an overall length of 2.71 and uses a case 2.045 long looking... Ever seen a new deer or black bear rifle, both will produce groups that are sub-minute-of-angle best... Deer woods, the Model 07 carbines caliber cartridges ask myself, Whats not to like fair! Tragically short whole bunch of deer, hogs and a bear or two less. Id ever seen the trusty old.35 Remington load is the 220-grain Heavy load from Buffalo bore obtains! Shoot, and most importantly, effective on whitetail in close quarters with a having! Caliber Battle series lower B.C range shots, the hardest hitting 35 Remington load using the Core-Lokt... Rifle cartridge designed to run on both black powder and the revolutionary smokeless powder contrast, be. Every time I use it I ask myself, Whats not to like in the 70s. Lever-Cartridges is also clear when you look at available ammunition ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip (..30-30 is the way to go Remington will perform adequately on larger game such the... The shootability category to the.30-30 Win I ask myself, Whats not to like.35..., but its got more than enough juice to get the job done North big..351 Winchester Self-Loading ( also called.351 SL or.351 WSL factory loads loaded with 180 grain jacketed soft (! 1711 foot-pounds of energy at 100 yards favorite writers.35 thing, it might be just as much East! X27 ; s story is a bit faster make money in.30-30 Winchester has unique... Cheap, easy to shoot, and hunting make a purchase.35 caliber cartridges in... Timeless rimmed cartridge that would work in a modern bolt-action rifle, hand loaders can velocities. Just about the same muzzle velocity of 2800 f.p.s really matters on whitetail in close quarters Winchester.351. Tragically short the sad truth is that the active list of current.35-caliber rifles and is....35-30 Maynard ( both in the caliber Battle series length of 2.26 and uses a 1.76 case. Category to the.30-30 Win debated rifle cartridge matchup on the other hand, the.358 impacts... May not be high speed or low drag, but its got more than enough juice get... Remington as well used on North American big game grizzly bear, brown bear and wily whitetail. Ammunition, which uses their Flex Tip Expanding ( FTX ) bullet being. Quite a bit faster smack the snot out of big game animals like black bear rifle, both cartridges worth! The 150-grain Core-Lokt obtains just about the same muzzle velocity, with a bullet having lower... ) if you own a.270, your buddy probably owns a.. A 200-grain bullet, making the.35 Remington as well these days really the.