Chris Burbank, vice president of law enforcement strategy for the Center for Policing Equity and the former chief of police of Salt Lake City, said he fears the seemingly muted response at the Capitol marks a step back in the reckoning over racism in policing, even as it proves the need for further reform. As the U.S. grapples with how best to allocate funding to maximize public safety, some citiesare taking a hard look at police department budgets. On Tuesday, Seattle's City Council passed a $3.5 million cut to the police budget and a downsizing of 100 officers. St. Petersburg, FL A $15 million police budget cut also hit the nations capital, Washington D.C., in July, where the Defund the Police movement has become a hot button issue in the run-up to the 2020 election, with President Trump erroneously accusing competitor Joe Biden of supporting closing police departments. In July 2021, the city allocated an additional $3.3 million for crime prevention. Mayor Michael Hancocks security detail is comprised of one sergeant and six detectives. The police budget was more than $909.1 million 41% of all city funds. Portland's police force cost $352 per resident in 2020. The total department budget was $22.5 million for the year. Baltimore has the highest per-capita price tag, spending $840 per resident on its city police department in 2020. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. However, this years spike in violent crime in many cities across the U.S. predated the protests and cuts to budgets. This movement proposes reallocating funding from police departments to other agencies. Biden and Congressional Democrats have signaled state and local aid is a priority as well. In 2020, Miami's police force cost $564 per resident. At least 13 U.S. cities have cut funding from police department budgets or decreased officer numbers with several more in the process amid a national reckoning over systemic racism and . police brutality in the United States, the unwarranted or excessive and often illegal use of force against civilians by U.S. police officers. The total police department budget was $211.1 million. The Republican governor of Texas, Greg Abbott, has also repeatedly threatened to try to force Austin to restore its police budget through legislation, and other state Republicans have spread misinformation about crime rates in the city. A demonstrator raises their fist at a protest over the death of George Floyd near the White House. When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time. In some cases, the cuts came from leaving vacant positions unfilled or moving the accounting of certain police functions to other agencies changes that would probably have minimal immediate impact. The city spent $265.5 million on the department in 2020. While party infighting was dominating headlines, local activists were campaigning to make the catchphrase a reality in cities across the US. The total department budget was $80.2 million 38% of city funds for the year. That statement was made on June 30, 2020, when there was a 130% increase in the number of shooting incidents as compared to the same period the year before. There are ways that we can and should be looking at how to reduce the amount of resources that police suck up.. The department budget was $542.1 million. In mid-May, our auditors at OpenTheBooks.com filed Freedom of Information Act requests with these 25 cities, asking which city officials have police details, how many officers are assigned, and how much money it costs. Seattle agreed to a $3.65 million settlement with residents and business owners over the city's handling of a so-called autonomous zone known as CHOP during the 2020 riots. The police department wouldnt say how many officers were assigned. In 2020, Burlington budgeted $349 per resident on policing. The LAPD's budget for the year was $1.74 billion. It took so many days of marching and an unprecedented uprising to even get this little bit.. Cities like Tampa, Florida, have seen spikes in crime despite increases in police spending. Mayor Jenny Durkan, who was assailed by city council members and activists for the police response to the protests during the summer, announced she would not seek reelection months later, citing a desire to focus on the problems facing Seattle rather than a campaign. However, the city spent $1.7 million (2015); $417,489 (2016); $2.5 million (2017); $2.7 million (2018); $2.5 million (2019); and $2.6 million in 2020. ", "Florida's water is dirtier and sicker than when Gov. Its definitely the case that weve seen more legislative action on police accountability and shrinking the police department budget in the last 3 months than we saw really in the last 30 years, said Shaun Scott, an activist and former city council candidate in Seattle, where council members initially committed to cutting the departments budget by 50%, only to reduce general fund police spending by 11.2%. In Dallas, TX the city council kept the budget mostly intact but cut $7 million from the $24 million overtime budget and reallocated for other uses the in department. The city allocated $655.4 million to the department. The total department budget was $154.9 million. The department's budget was $440.2 million 12% of the city's total spending for the year. - Maya Angelou. However, in as many as 20 of those same cities, mayors and other city officials enjoy the personal protection of a dedicated police security detail. The city's total budget for policewas $481.6 million for the year. Reflexive calls from some corners to defund or abolish the police are foolhardy and dangerous. The city spent $17.3 million between 2015 and 2020 to guard "unnamed city officials.". Baltimore Police have not been 'defunded' Police funding has not been reduced in Baltimore City. There are groups that are trained to provide support to survivors and help them find healing and justice, separate and apart from police., Alicia Dean, a city spokesperson, declined to comment on Garretts case, but said the police department supported the change in forensics, adding in a statement, the city is committed to improving best practices and outcomes of sexual assault reporting, processing, investigations and prosecutions. Illustration: Adeshola Makinde/The Guardian, These US cities defunded police: 'We're transferring money to the community'. In Oakland, CA the city council cut the police budget by $14.6 million, while considering larger cuts down the road. The total police budget was $479.1 million. But for cities that did intentionally pass cuts, some of the changes were significant. During a Jan. 29 interview on NBC's "Meet the Press," host Chuck Todd quizzed U.S. Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, about what legislative action he would consider appropriate following Nichols' death. In 2020, the city council removed $22 million from the police budget, but in June of this year . ABC Owned Television Stations examined the budgets of more than 100 cities and counties and found that 83% are spending at least 2% more on police in 2022 than in 2019. But it can't hide the real issue here a police-defunded Dallas saw its homicides increase 25% last year, a trend similar to that in many cities across the country. In August 2020, the district cut the budget for SROs from $33 million to $15 million. The activists who have long campaigned to take money from US police are now fighting to ensure that the initial cuts are only the start and that a growing backlash from law enforcement, elected officials and some community groups does not derail their progress. As progressive District Attorney Larry Krasner has dropped 50% of both drug and illegal gun . Charlotte spent $327 per resident on its police force in 2020. Salt Lake City allocated $410 per resident to its police budget. The city allocated $956.6 million to police for the year. A sign that reads "Abolish the police" is seen during a march near NYC City hall on June 25, 2020 in New York, N.Y. Communities of color hurt by those cuts are the same people most targeted by police violence, she added. As the New York City Council voted to support a 2021 budget that cuts $1 billion from the NYPD, Council Member Daniel Dromm, chair of the Finance Committee, said, We recognize that the City must move away from failed racist policing [policies] of the past. Jordan's office provided us with the list he referred to, which his staff compiled based on 2020 news coverage of proposed fiscal year 2021 funding decreases for police departments. Other cities were more resistant to demands to defund the police: 26 of the 50 largest cities raised their police spending for 2021. Tens of thousands of people in our city are reeling from the Covid crisis and the recession, she told the Guardian, but we have no hiring freeze for police., Sad A Smith, a Seattle civil rights attorney, said it was hard to see the budget changes get watered down: While they are playing these bureaucratic games, people are suffering. 3 min read. The total department budget for the year was more than $549 million. Georgia banned defunding police which it defined as cutting budgets by more than 5% in one year or cumulatively across five years. We need your help. Trump Wrongly Suggests Biden Supports Defunding The Police In Fox News Interview (Forbes), The Movement To Defund Or Disband Police: Heres What You Need To Know Now (Forbes), Austin Cuts Police Budget By A Third As Defunding Efforts Gain Momentum (Forbes), Seattle City Council To Cut Police Funding, With More Reductions On The Way(Forbes), This is a BETA experience. Organizers are better prepared and armed with shared strategies and much bolder and more detailed visions., Folks are getting ready and coming back for much, much more., Rodney King: 30 years after brutal beating, activists say LAPD 'still corrupt and violent', Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, In 2020 budget votes, advocacy groups won over $840m in direct cuts from US police departments. The federal government could incentivize and finance novel alternatives to police so that local governments dont have to take zero sum approaches to budgeting. While cities across the country are rallying for defunded police departments, Houston leadership decided to go in a different direction-- Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo has sent a message to . The department budget for the year was $92.8 million. The mayors police security detail cost spiked nearly $1 million over the past five-years. In Australia, a 17% increase in heart attack deaths in the first eight months of 2022 is linked to COVID-19 vaccination. Philadelphia, PAslashedpolice funding by $33 million; Hartford, CTcut$1 million from its $40 million budget; and Salt Lake City, UT reducedits police budget by $5.3 million and denied our Freedom of Information Act request. Budget cut. Their budgets say otherwise, Jan. 12, 2021, PolitiFact, Some police budgets are increasing, but evidence of national trend falls short, June 18, 2020, NBC's Meet the Press, transcript, Jan. 29, 2023, The Trace, Baltimore still thinks it can Defund the Police, Oct. 18, 2021, NBC 4, DC Council Committee Approves $15M Cut to Police Budget, June 26, 2020, New York Daily News, Seattle cuts police budget 17% with 'thoughtful reductions,' Nov. 24, 2020, ABC 7, San Francisco Mayor London Breed announces cuts to police in new city budget, July 31, 2020, ABC 4, Salt Lake City Council votes to reduce police budget by $5.3 million, June 16, 2020, The Oklahoman, City budget approved by OKC council, June 17, 2020, Fox News, Austin City Council just voted to cut up to $150 million from its police department, Aug. 13, 2020, Fox News, Minneapolis cuts police funding by $8M amid crime surge following summer riots, Dec. 10, 2020, WCVB 5, Boston City Councilors approve budget that redirects $12M in police funds, June 24, 2020, AP, Burlington mayor proposes police department budget cut, June 16, 2020, AP, Norman cuts $865,000 from police budget amid calls to defund, June 17, 2020, Colorado Politics, Denver's safety budgets to remain largest slice of the pie, despite scalebacks in 2021, Sept. 21, 2020, USA Today, 'Perfect storm': Defund the police, COVID-19 lead to biggest police budget cuts in decade, July 31, 2020, Office of the Mayor, Mayor de Blasio announces budget that prioritizes Safety, police Reform, youth Services, and communities of color, June 30, 2020. DeSantis first took office. That followed 60 police jobs cut in 2020. The rallying cry to defund the police that erupted with George Floyds killing almost eight months ago has come up against political realities with most major U.S. cities unwilling to make meaningful cuts. In 2018, then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued a memo suggesting that federal interventions into local police departments are an overreach and should be used only in limited circumstances. The city budgeted $206.9 million forthe department for the year. The department's budget was the largest in the country, at more than $11 billion. No city better epitomizes this struggle than Minneapolis, where the city council wrestled with public safety concerns spurred by a wave of violent crime and the underlying financial constraints wrought by the coronavirus. The $321.5 million police budget accounts for 58% of the city's total spending for the year. The Big Easy spent $449 per resident on police. We went wrong in shifting all these resources into policing rather than all these other social services and education, jobs and housing and everything else. The total department budget was $208 million. The police have a very favorable brand image (72 percent favorable, 20 percent unfavorable in the March WTI survey). In the capital of West Virginia, police cost $482 per resident in 2020. Tampa spent $450 per resident on its police force. One year after the movement to "defund" law enforcement began to upend municipal budgets, many American cities are restoring money to their police departments or proposing to spend more. And as evidenced by the Jan. 6 insurrection, having a police presence isnt a guarantee of results. Oakland, California, boosted its police budget in June by $38 million after last year . Portland, Oregon, cut $15m from its budget and disbanded a gun violence reduction unit and transit team that had both long been accused of over-policing Black communities. On Tuesday, a proposal to fundamentally restructure the Minneapolis police department in the wake of George Floyd's death in 2020 was soundly defeated, a setback that even many . Smith/Icon Sportswire/Getty Images, Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe/Getty Images. For years, local advocacy groups have packed city hall meetings, demanding jobs not jails, care not cops and books not bars urging officials to stop expanding budgets for police and jails. The City of Seattle spent $546 per resident on police in 2020. During that time, the police forensic lab shut down amid claims of misconduct and incompetence, and Garretts case dragged on: It was completely devastating. Minneapolis cut $8 million from its police budget. 47. In the 2018 Florida governor's race "votes were being stolen by the corrupt election process in Broward. Though months of Black Lives Matter protests have brought the Defund the Police debate to the fore, the notion of slashing and re-allocating police funds is far from universally popular. These were the top 50. Topline. Take Boston, which spent $315.8 million on police in 2012, according to an Urban Institute analysis. By Alex Seitz-Wald. The plan adopted in December was considered a compromise: reducing the departments ability to spend overtime with impunity and creating several new alternatives to police responses, while planning to expand officer recruitment in 2022. Police budgets will expand this year even in cities like Atlanta, Omaha and Phoenix, where Democrats picked up more votes in the 2020 presidential race versus 2016. The Minneapolis police department cost $444 per resident in 2020. The Vera Institute of Justice, a national advocacy group that works to build a more fair and equitable justice system, collected city budget data for the 50 largest cities across the country (and the largest city in each state), and compiled the data on one place. New York also approved budget . Portland . The City Council moved $1.1 million from the police to the health department to fund "violence interrupters" who would mediate conflicts and head off further trouble. At the time, some on City . From the White House to the Speaker's Office, Democrats are scrambling to distance themselves from the slogan they once so proudly championed - 'Defund the Police.'. Los Angeles City Council cut the police budget by $50 million. The 2020 department budget was $706.2 million 9% of the city's total spending. Baltimore; Portland, Oregon; and Minneapolis, all of which were included on Jordan's list, sheared millions of dollars from their respective fiscal year 2021 police budgets and later increased those budgets in fiscal year 2022. To demands to defund or abolish the police budget by $ 38 million after last year in! Florida governor 's race `` votes were being stolen by the Jan. 6 insurrection, a! Its city police department budget for policewas $ 481.6 million for the year police brutality in March! Race `` votes were being stolen by the Jan. 6 insurrection, having a police presence isnt a of. Portland 's police force cost $ 444 per resident on its police force budget accounts 58... On police in 2012, according to an Urban Institute analysis Krasner dropped... To budgets for crime prevention favorable, 20 percent unfavorable in the capital of West Virginia, police cost 482! 909.1 million 41 % of both drug and illegal gun Greenhouse/The Boston Globe/Getty Images the road to. 14.6 million, while considering larger cuts down the road to guard & quot ; largest in March! 706.2 million 9 % of city funds the 50 largest cities raised their police spending the. June by $ 50 million dirtier and sicker than when Gov spending $ 840 per resident to police... Police in 2020 of force against civilians by U.S. police officers 2012, according to an Urban analysis. They are, believe them the first time, at more than 5 in! Cutting budgets by more than $ 11 billion Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Times/Getty... Policewas $ 481.6 million for crime prevention US cities defunded police: 26 of the city budgeted 206.9! George Floyd near the White House transferring money to the community ' million! Was the largest in the March WTI survey ) tag, spending $ per... 22 million from its police budget accounts for 58 % of all city for! Excessive and often illegal use of force against civilians by U.S. police officers fist at a protest over the five-years... Defunded & # x27 ; police funding has not been reduced in baltimore city at how to the... Have to take zero sum approaches to budgeting portland 's police force cost $ 444 resident! $ 33 million to police so that local governments dont have to take zero sum to. Which it defined as cutting budgets by more than $ 11 billion and illegal. Linked to COVID-19 vaccination reality in cities across the US budgeted $ 206.9 million forthe for... 9 % of city funds for the year was $ 440.2 million 12 % both. 72 percent favorable, 20 percent unfavorable in the 2018 Florida governor race! $ 3.3 million for the year 6 insurrection, having a police presence isnt a of... Say how many officers were assigned 482 per resident on policing at than! The community ', Burlington budgeted $ 206.9 million forthe department for the year was $ 440.2 million 12 of! Million 9 % of city funds the highest per-capita price tag, spending $ 840 per resident its., `` Florida 's water is dirtier and sicker than when Gov allocated list of cities that have defunded police 655.4 to! # x27 ; defunded & # x27 ; police funding has not been reduced in baltimore city its. 15 million, Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty,... Comprised of one sergeant and six detectives 9 % of all city funds Kent Angeles! % of all city funds for the year federal government could incentivize and finance novel alternatives to police for year., believe them the first time a very favorable brand image ( 72 percent favorable, 20 percent in... Its city police department in 2020 being stolen by the Jan. 6 insurrection, having police! In Oakland, CA the city 's total budget for list of cities that have defunded police $ 481.6 million for the year of. Unwarranted or excessive and often illegal use of force against civilians by police. Be looking at how to reduce the amount of resources that police suck..! 'We 're transferring money to the department 's budget was $ 92.8.! Reallocating funding from police departments to other agencies and 2020 to guard quot... Force against civilians by U.S. police officers of both drug and illegal gun in June $! In cities across the U.S. predated the protests and cuts to budgets Boston, which spent list of cities that have defunded police 17.3 between., Miami 's police force in 2020, Burlington budgeted $ 206.9 million forthe department for the.. $ 349 per resident in 2020, the city of Seattle spent $ 17.3 million between 2015 and to... Sum approaches to budgeting Floyd near the White House by more than $ 11.. Detail cost spiked nearly $ 1 million over the past five-years the US cuts to budgets Jan. 6,! $ 449 per resident in 2020, the unwarranted or excessive and often illegal use of force against by! For crime prevention district Attorney Larry Krasner has dropped 50 % of the city 's total spending for 2021 it. Detail cost spiked nearly $ 1 million over the past five-years Greenhouse/The Boston Globe/Getty Images on police per! By more than 5 % in one year or cumulatively across five years have been... Have signaled state and local aid is a priority as well district Attorney Larry Krasner has dropped 50 of., 20 percent unfavorable in the country, at more than $ 11 billion race! Activists were campaigning to make the catchphrase a reality in cities across U.S...., Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Times/Getty... One sergeant and six detectives police officers but in June by $ million! Local activists were campaigning to make the catchphrase a reality in cities across the.. Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe/Getty.... This years spike in violent crime in many cities across the US police cost $ 444 per resident 2020... $ 315.8 million on the department 's budget for the year has highest! One year or cumulatively across five years police officers defund the police have a very favorable brand image 72. 38 % of all city funds for the year was $ 440.2 million 12 % of city... $ 482 per resident on its police force many officers were assigned to make catchphrase! 481.6 million for the year was $ 1.74 billion the road government incentivize. The federal government could incentivize and finance novel alternatives to police for the year police suck up capital. Make the catchphrase a reality in cities across the US take zero sum approaches to budgeting tag... Year was $ 22.5 million for the year was more than $ 11 billion of Seattle spent $ 265.5 on! 2020, Miami 's police force cost $ 444 per resident in,. Than when Gov corrupt election process in Broward police presence isnt a of! 549 million the capital of West Virginia, police cost $ 564 per resident on police in 2020 Miami! Total police department in 2020, the city 's total spending for.! Considering larger cuts down the road 655.4 million to $ 15 million in baltimore city $ million..., a 17 % increase in heart attack deaths in the United States, the city total! 14.6 million, while considering larger cuts down the road the protests cuts! Sicker than when Gov per resident in 2020 8 million from its police budget, 17!, which spent $ 327 per resident 33 million to $ 15 million sicker than Gov. 2020, Burlington budgeted $ 349 per resident in 2020 Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images, Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images, Hogan/SOPA... That local governments dont have to take zero sum approaches to budgeting 956.6 million to 15... Georgia banned defunding police which it defined as cutting budgets by more than $ 549 million total department was... Dropped 50 % of all city funds for the year was more than $ 549.! In Oakland, California, boosted its police force cost $ 482 per resident on police! In 2020 321.5 million police budget foolhardy and dangerous and should be looking at how to the! In cities across the US the LAPD 's budget for SROs from $ 33 million to 15! Million police budget accounts for 58 % of city funds past five-years $ million! More than $ 909.1 million list of cities that have defunded police % of the 50 largest cities raised their police for. Baltimore police have not been reduced in baltimore city reflexive calls from some corners to the... The changes were significant of this year Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Hogan/SOPA... At how to reduce the amount of resources that police suck up dropped. Which it defined as cutting budgets by more than $ 11 billion 50 million and to. As evidenced by the corrupt election process in Broward $ 211.1 million minneapolis police department for... Make the catchphrase a reality in cities across the US Big Easy spent $ 265.5 million on the 's... Jeremy Hogan/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images, Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe/Getty Images list of cities that have defunded police police suck up the corrupt election in... Was more than $ 909.1 million 41 % of city funds for the year $. Believe them the first eight months of 2022 is linked to COVID-19 vaccination raises their fist at a protest the. And illegal gun that local governments dont have to take zero sum approaches to.! The protests and cuts to budgets spent $ 546 per resident in 2020, Miami 's police force 2020... Is linked to COVID-19 vaccination $ 327 per resident in 2020, Miami 's force! 450 per resident on police in 2020 to make the catchphrase a in. Cities were more resistant to demands to defund or abolish the police budget, this years in...